Author Topic: What happens to your suggestion?  (Read 1870 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Manuel Pendejo

  • BETA Tester
  • Hero Member
  • **********
  • Posts: 2242
  • If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong
    • View Profile
What happens to your suggestion?
« on: October 19, 2009, 12:26:48 pm »
After your suggestion has been posted, it can either be moved to the Accepted board, the Denied board, or it can be deleted.

Your suggestion is Accepted when:
-The suggestion is proven to be a valuable addition to the server, and the advantages outweigh the disadvantages.
-Your opponents are no longer able to provide proper argumentation as to why not to implement your suggestion.
-A clear majority of the people agrees with your suggestion.
-Your first post has been updated with all the input given by the community (Important one. If this hasn't been done, your suggestion won't be accepted yet. This is all to speed up the process of adding these suggestions, so Redgie doesn't have to go through 5 pages of discussion before he knows what the suggestion is about)

(Your suggestion usually has to comply to all these terms before it can be accepted, although there always are some exceptions)

Once your suggestion has been accepted, it's up to Redgie whether or not to add it. After all, Redgie has the final say in these things. If your suggestion is no longer in the Accepted board, it's either moved to the Added board, or the Denied board.

Your suggestion is Denied when:
-You're no longer able to provide proper argumentation as to why your suggestion should be implemented.
-The disadvantages of your idea outweigh the advantages of your idea.
-A clear majority disagrees with your suggestion.
-The suggestion is not needed (it's already there, or it has no effect on the server at all)
-Your suggestion is unscriptable

(Your suggestion usually has to comply with all these terms before it can be denied, although there always are some exceptions)

The reasons for either an acception or denial will be given as a quote including 1 or more of these terms

Your suggestion is deleted when:
-You posted 2 suggestions in 1 topic.
-You didn't post your suggestion in (understandable) English. Your English doesn't have to be perfect, but if nobody is able to understand what you're saying, there's no point in keeping it there.
-You break any regular forum rules (double-posting, flaming, etc)
-The suggestion you posted has already been posted by someone else.

You will not be given a warning/PM to notify of your topic's deletion, so if you can't find your topic in any board, it has probably been deleted for any of the above reasons.

(Your suggestion only has to comply with 1 of these terms before it can be deleted, no exceptions)
« Last Edit: October 21, 2009, 04:10:10 pm by Morgan Freeman »